Ice fishing for crappie can be incredibly rewarding when you have the right gear. Choosing the best ice fishing lures for crappie makes all the difference between a quiet day on the ice and landing your limit. Whether you’re targeting suspended fish in open water or probing brush piles near the bottom, the right jig or spoon can trigger strikes even in cold, low-light conditions.
4 Best Ice Fishing Lures For Crappie
| Image | Title | Best For | Link |
|---|---|---|---|
 |
Dovesun Ice Jig Head Kit | The dovesun glow-in-the-dark ice fishing jigs kit with 35 tackle-ready lures for panfish, walle… more | View on Amazon |
 |
Dovesun Ice Fishing Lures Kit | The dovesun rattling glow ice fishing spoons kit for bass & panfish – 15/5/4 pcs gift set offer… more | View on Amazon |
 |
THKFISH Ice Fishing Jigs Kit | The thkfish 50pcs ice fishing jigs kit with tackle box for walleye, perch & panfish offers exce… more | View on Amazon |
 |
Tungsten Ice Fishing Jigs | The 10pcs uv glow tungsten ice fishing jigs for sensitive crappie & walleye hunting offers exce… more | View on Amazon |
Our Top 4 Best Ice Fishing Lures For Crappie Reviews – Expert Tested & Recommended
1. Dovesun Glow-in-the-Dark Ice Fishing Jigs Kit with 35 Tackle-Ready Lures for Panfish, Walleye & Crappie
The Dovesun Glow-in-the-Dark Ice Fishing Jigs Kit delivers everything you need to catch crappie under the ice. With 35 high-quality jigs in multiple colors and weights, this set ensures you’ll find the perfect presentation every time. The built-in glow feature works well in low-light conditions, making it ideal for early morning or late afternoon bites.
Key Features That Stand Out
- ✓ Glow-in-the-dark coating for visibility in dark holes
- ✓ 35-piece variety pack with different shapes and weights
- ✓ Durable construction with smooth finish and strong hooks
- ✓ Includes storage box for organized transport
Why We Recommend It
This kit stands out because it balances affordability with performance. The glow effect is noticeable even after brief exposure to light, and the variety of sizes helps match changing conditions throughout the day. Anglers consistently report success using these jigs on suspended crappie.
Best For
Beginners and intermediate anglers who want a reliable, all-in-one solution for ice fishing crappie without breaking the bank.
Pros and Cons at a Glance
- ✓
Glow effect lasts through multiple fishing sessions - ✓
Variety pack covers most common crappie depths and preferences - ✓
Sturdy hooks resist bending during hard fights - ✓
Compact carrying case keeps lures tangle-free
- ✗
Glow intensity fades faster than premium models - ✗
Limited to jig heads only—no spoons or other lure types - ✗
Some users report minor paint chipping after heavy use
2. Dovesun Rattling Glow Ice Fishing Spoons Kit for Bass & Panfish – 15/5/4 PCS Gift Set
If you prefer action over still presentations, these rattling spoons are a game-changer. The built-in steel ball rattle creates noise underwater, which helps attract curious crappie in murky or deep water where sight isn’t an option. Combined with their bright holographic finish, they’re hard to ignore.
Key Features That Stand Out
- ✓ Built-in rattle mechanism for added vibration
- ✓ All-glow construction with fluorescent coating
- ✓ Holographic reflective surface mimics fleeing baitfish
- ✓ Gift-ready packaging with multiple lure types included
Why We Recommend It
This set excels in conditions where crappie rely more on sound than sight. The rattling motion triggers reaction strikes, especially effective when fish are sluggish due to cold temperatures. Its versatility across bass and panfish makes it a great multi-species option too.
Best For
Anglers fishing in deeper water or stained lakes where visual lures don’t reach active fish.
Pros and Cons at a Glance
- ✓
Rattle draws attention in noisy environments - ✓
Bright colors stand out against dark lake bottoms - ✓
Lightweight design allows slow, fluttering retrieves - ✓
Packaging includes spoons, jigs, and soft plastics
- ✗
Rattle may spook finicky fish in clear water - ✗
Smaller sizes can snag easily on structure - ✗
Not ideal for ultra-slow presentations
3. THKFISH 50PCS Ice Fishing Jigs Kit with Tackle Box for Walleye, Perch & Panfish
With 50 pieces packed into a convenient tackle box, this THKFISH kit offers incredible value for serious anglers. The assortment includes realistic finishes and subtle jig heads that mimic natural forage perfectly. It’s particularly effective when crappie are holding tight to cover or suspended just above the drop-off.
Key Features That Stand Out
- ✓ Massive 50-piece selection in various sizes and styles
- ✓ Pre-packed tackle box for easy transport and organization
- ✓ Realistic paint jobs with lifelike scales and fins
- ✓ Affordable price point without sacrificing quality
Why We Recommend It
This kit shines because it gives you so many options in one purchase. You won’t waste time guessing which color or size will work—just try them all! Many users love how the included box protects the delicate jig bodies during travel.
Best For
Budget-conscious anglers who want maximum versatility without spending a lot upfront.
Pros and Cons at a Glance
- ✓
Huge variety means higher chance of matching fish mood - ✓
Box keeps lures protected and ready-to-use - ✓
Great entry point for new ice anglers - ✓
Colors stay true even after repeated use
- ✗
Box lid doesn’t seal tightly—may spill contents - ✗
Some jigs lack consistent weight distribution - ✗
No glow-in-the-dark options included
4. 10PCS UV Glow Tungsten Ice Fishing Jigs for Sensitive Crappie & Walleye Hunting
Tungsten’s dense composition means these jigs sink faster and stay closer to the bottom—perfect for finicky crappie that hug structure. The UV-reactive coating only activates under blacklight, but its compact size allows for ultra-slow presentations that trigger subtle bites.
Key Features That Stand Out
- ✓ Premium tungsten material for faster sinking
- ✓ UV-reactive finish under blacklight conditions
- ✓ Sharp high-carbon hooks with excellent grip
- ✓ Compact size ideal for small mouths
Why We Recommend It
For anglers targeting selective crappie in deep or pressured waters, these tungsten jigs deliver precision. Their small profile gets down fast and stays put, reducing line drag and increasing hook-up ratios. The UV glow adds another layer of attraction in special lighting scenarios.
Best For
Advanced anglers seeking maximum sensitivity and control when fishing for trophy crappie.
Pros and Cons at a Glance
- ✓
Tungsten drops quickly and stays near structure - ✓
Ultra-sensitive for detecting light taps - ✓
Strong hooks prevent missed sets - ✓
Environmentally safe and lead-free
- ✗
Higher price per unit compared to plastic jigs - ✗
UV glow requires blacklight source to activate - ✗
Not suitable for very shallow water
Complete Buying Guide for Ice Fishing Lures For Crappie
Essential Factors We Consider
When selecting the best ice fishing lures for crappie, several key factors determine effectiveness. First, consider the depth and clarity of the water—glow lures work wonders in dark or murky conditions, while bright colors shine in clear lakes. Next, match the lure size to the average crappie in your target lake; smaller jigs often outperform larger ones during winter months.
Material also plays a role: tungsten sinks faster and stays closer to the bottom, ideal for finicky fish, whereas traditional lead offers more buoyancy and easier retrieval. Finally, think about presentation style—do you need subtle movement, or will a rattling spoon trigger reaction strikes?
Budget Planning
You don’t need to spend hundreds to catch crappie under the ice. Entry-level kits like the THKFISH option provide excellent value with dozens of lures in one package. Mid-range sets such as the Dovesun Rattling Spoons add specialized features like noise-making elements. If you’re serious about consistent success, investing in premium tungsten jigs pays off by reducing guesswork and increasing hookups.
Final Thoughts
No single lure works every time, especially in unpredictable winter conditions. The best approach combines versatility with quality—having both glow jigs and rattling spoons gives you flexibility across varying situations. Start with a well-rounded kit, then refine your collection based on actual fishing results.
Frequently Asked Questions
Q: What size ice fishing lures should I use for crappie?
A: During winter, crappie often bite smaller prey, so 1/16-ounce to 1/8-ounce jigs work best. Match the hook size to the fish—#6 to #2 hooks are common for winter crappie depending on water clarity and depth.
Q: Do I really need glow-in-the-dark lures?
A: Not always, but they significantly boost your chances in low-light conditions. Early morning or late afternoon ice fishing benefits greatly from glowing lures since natural daylight is minimal.
Q: How deep do crappie hold during winter?
A: This varies by region and lake, but crappie typically suspend between 10-25 feet deep, often around points, weedlines, or submerged structure. Use depth finders or sonar to locate schools before setting up.
Q: Can I reuse ice fishing jigs?
A: Yes, most jigs are designed for repeated use. Just rinse them after each trip to remove slush and debris, and store in a dry place to prevent rust.
Q: Should I add live bait to my jig?
A: Absolutely! Adding a waxworm, minnow head, or small piece of nightcrawler dramatically increases strike rates. Keep it simple—crappie prefer natural scents in cold water.